The Complete Beginner's Guide to PSA Grading: What You Need to Know

Home / Blog / The Complete Beginner's Guide to PSA Grading: What You Need to Know

Phantom Display Aug 30, 2023 0 comments

The world of trading cards and collectibles is growing at a breakneck pace, driven by the nostalgia of long-time hobbyists and the fresh enthusiasm of new collectors. Whether you’re passionate about classic baseball cards, the latest basketball rookies, or fan-favorite Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering sets, the condition of your cards is critical in determining their overall value and collectibility.

That’s where PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator) steps in. PSA, alongside Beckett Grading Services (BGS), is one of the two most recognized third-party card grading companies in the market. PSA’s reputation for reliability and consistency has made it the largest and most trusted grading authority in the collectibles world. In this extensive blog post, we’ll cover, in detail, why the PSA grading scale is so crucial, how PSA determines your card’s grade, and how these grades can dramatically affect the value and desirability of your cards. By the end, you’ll have a deeper understanding of how PSA’s signature red-labeled slabs have become a cornerstone of the trading card hobby.

Why the PSA grading scale matters

Industry standard and recognition
PSA launched in 1991 and has graded tens of millions of cards since then, placing it at the forefront of the trading card industry. When you’re selling or buying PSA-graded cards, buyers worldwide have a shared confidence and understanding of what a particular grade means. This universal acceptance of PSA’s standards helps ensure your graded cards remain highly liquid and desirable.
Objective, third-party assessment
PSA’s 10-point scale is more than just numbers—each grade comes with precise criteria that apply to critical areas like centering, corners, edges, and surface. Because these standards are published and well-established, grading by PSA removes much of the subjectivity and guesswork that can come with evaluating card condition on your own.
Value amplification
A PSA-graded card, especially one graded “Gem Mint 10,” can command a notable premium in the market. Even mid-tier or lower grades from PSA can see higher resale values compared to equivalent raw (ungraded) cards, thanks to the authenticity guarantee. For vintage cards, a PSA 2 or 3 can sell for a hefty sum when rarity factors in (e.g., the famed T206 Honus Wagner).
Population reports and scarcity
One unique feature of PSA is its population report—a constantly updated tally of how many times a particular card has been graded at each grade level. This data allows collectors to better gauge a card’s rarity in high grades. For example, if a certain vintage card only has 10 copies that achieved a PSA 9, it underscores that card’s scarcity and can significantly drive its market price.
Tamper-evident protection
After a card is graded, PSA seals it in a protective, tamper-evident holder using ultrasonic welding. This “slab” not only keeps your card safe from physical harm but also deters any attempts at altering or trimming the card in the future. Consequently, a buyer can feel secure that the card hasn’t been compromised since encapsulation.

Key factors in PSA grading

Understanding the four primary criteria that PSA graders focus on helps demystify why cards often earn the grades they do.

Centering
- Definition & Importance: Centering is how evenly the image and borders on a card are aligned. A perfectly centered card is crucial for top-notch eye appeal; this is one of the first aspects a PSA grader checks.
- How It’s Judged: PSA graders measure the borders from top-to-bottom and left-to-right. Slight shifts can be acceptable (e.g., 60/40 front centering for a PSA 9), but the more off-center the card, the lower the potential grade.
Corners
- Definition & Importance: Inspecting corners is vital, as they’re the first parts of a card to show damage through handling. Faded or blunted corners can significantly lower the grade of an otherwise pristine card.
- Tips for Collectors: For modern cards (post-2000), collectors often store them immediately in sleeves and toploaders to maintain sharp corners. Vintage cards naturally tend to show corner wear, which influences how PSA assigns grades.
Edges
- Definition & Importance: The edges of a card frame its design, and damage to edges often includes chipping, fraying, or nicks. On older sets, colored edges (such as 1971 Topps Baseball) are notoriously difficult to keep pristine, because even the slightest white chip will stand out.
- Impact on Grade: A card with near-perfect corners could still be knocked down a grade or two if its edges are significantly chipped or frayed.
Surface
- Definition & Importance: The front and back surfaces are inspected for print lines, scratches, dimples, stains, or discoloration. A card’s surface is often the most challenging element to maintain, as it can be marred by factory defects, mishandling, or even slight manufacturing flaws like roller lines.
- Common Issues: Wax or gum stains (especially in vintage sports sets), factory printing lines, and holographic scratches on Pokémon or Magic cards. The severity of these blemishes can determine whether a card slips from a 10 down to a 9, 8, or even lower.

Deep dive: The PSA grading scale from 1 to 10

The PSA grading scale ranges from 1 (Poor) to 10 (Gem Mint). While the numerical system is straightforward, each grade has unique descriptors that reflect its overall quality.

Grade	Abbreviation	Description	Key Characteristics
10	Gem Mint	Virtually perfect	Perfect centering (or close), razor-sharp corners, flawless surface, no visible wear. The pinnacle of grading.
9	MINT 9	Extremely minor flaws only	Slight centering issues (60/40 to 65/35 on front), sharp corners, minimal surface flaws. Highly sought-after, second only to PSA 10.
8	NM-MT 8	Near Mint-Mint	Minor corner frays or printing imperfections, centering up to 70/30, slight surface or edge issues but still excellent eye appeal.
7	NM 7	Near Mint	Mild surface wear, subtle corner or edge fraying, and minor scuffing. Looks great overall, still considered high-quality.
6	EX-MT 6	Excellent-Mint	Noticeable flaws, moderate corner wear, potential surface scratches, but no major issues that ruin overall appearance.
5	EX 5	Excellent	Clear signs of wear, minor rounding of corners, possibly a small crease or scratch. Solid, respectable condition for vintage cards.
4	VG-EX 4	Very Good-Excellent	Obvious wear on corners and edges, possible light scuffs or fading, likely small creases or mild staining.
3	VG 3	Very Good	Noticeable rounding of corners, general surface wear or scratching, edges may be worn or lightly scuffed.
2	GOOD 2	Good condition	Major rounding of corners, significant surface or edge wear, mild staining or discoloration.
1.5	FR 1.5	Fair condition	Substantial corner wear, heavy scuffs, chipping, or staining, but card is still identifiable.
1	PR 1	Poor condition	Potentially missing pieces, major creasing, extreme discoloration, or other severe damage.
NO	Authentic Only	Authentic, no numeric grade	The card is genuine but doesn’t receive a numeric grade (e.g., a notable autograph or card that PSA only authenticates).
AA	Authentic Altered	Authenticated, but altered	Card is confirmed authentic but has been tampered with (trimmed, recolored, or otherwise modified).

Why Low Grades Can Still Shine

Historical Significance: Cards like the iconic 1909–11 T206 Honus Wagner might only merit a PSA 1, yet are worth millions of dollars because of their rarity and legendary status.
Rarity Factor: Some sets are so rare that only a handful of copies exist in any grade. Thus, even heavily worn or “Poor” examples are highly sought after.

The Impact of PSA Grades on Card Value

Higher Grades, Higher Prices
The closer you get to a PSA 10, the bigger the price jump. A modern card graded a PSA 9 might be worth a fraction of its PSA 10 equivalent—sometimes half or even less. When you’re dealing with vintage, the difference between a PSA 8 and a PSA 9 can also be substantial.
Rarity and Scarcity
If a card is notoriously tough to grade due to centering or print defects, high-grade copies can skyrocket in value. For instance, some older sets are plagued by off-center printing, making any PSA 9 or 10 examples highly coveted.
Authentication and Peace of Mind
PSA’s global reputation is a safety net for collectors worried about counterfeits. The red label quickly signals authenticity, making it far easier to sell or trade.
Faster, Easier Transactions
In auctions, PSA-graded cards usually attract more bidders, and they often close at higher final sale prices. Collectors also find that selling or trading PSA-graded cards can happen faster because potential buyers trust the assigned grade.
Vintage vs. Modern
- Modern Cards (2003–Present for TCG, 2017–Present for sports): Often held to a higher standard—collectors expect them to be near-perfect.
- Vintage Cards: Can retain monumental value even in lower grades due to their sheer rarity and historical significance.

How PSA grades and encapsulates cards

Authentication check
- Verification: PSA experts ensure the card is legitimate and hasn’t been altered or trimmed. This process typically includes black light inspections, texture checks, and comparing font and printing details against known authentic examples.
Grading process
- Multiple Graders: Often, more than one expert will look at a card before a final consensus grade is reached.
- Detail-Oriented: Specialized tools, magnifying lenses, centering gauges, and angled lighting are used to detect minuscule flaws.
Ultrasonic sealing and labeling
- Encapsulation: The card is placed in a protective sleeve, then sealed into a tamper-evident PSA holder.
- Label Information: The label includes the card’s description, grade, and a unique certification number. PSA also logs a high-resolution scan and this certification number in its database.
Registry and population reports
- Tracking: PSA’s population report tallies how many cards of a specific type have been graded at each grade level.
- PSA Registry: Collectors can showcase their graded sets online, compare notes, and compete for the highest-rated set.

PSA submission process and tips

Select your service level
- PSA offers multiple tiers (e.g., Value, Regular, Express, Super Express) with varying turnaround times and costs. These are largely determined by your card’s declared value and how quickly you want it back.
Prepare your cards
- Penny Sleeves and Semi-Rigid Holders: Place each card in a soft penny sleeve, then into a semi-rigid card saver.
- Cleanliness: Wipe the surface gently with a microfiber cloth (especially for modern cards) to remove fingerprints or dust.
Fill out the submission form
- Online Submission Center: Input card details (year, set, card number, declared value).
- Declared Value: This ensures your cards are properly insured during shipping and while at PSA.
Secure shipping
- Packaging: Use strong cardboard, bubble wrap, and a sturdy box. Rubber-band your card savers lightly to keep them from shifting.
- Insurance and Tracking: Always insure your package for its declared value and get a tracking number.
Waiting period
- Turnaround Times: These can fluctuate based on PSA’s backlog, especially during industry booms. Standard service might take a few weeks to a few months; higher-priced tiers can be returned much faster (sometimes within 3–5 business days).
Receive your graded cards
- Inspection: Once you get your cards back, verify that the labels are correct and the slabs are intact.

How PSA stacks up against other grading services

While PSA is the largest and most recognized, it’s worth noting other top-tier options:

Beckett Grading Services (BGS): Known for subgrades (centering, corners, edges, surface) and the coveted “Black Label” (quad 10s). Some collectors appreciate BGS’s thick, sturdy slabs.
Certified Guaranty Company (CGC): A newcomer in the trading card space, CGC initially rose to fame grading comic books. CGC is often chosen for Pokémon and Magic cards and also offers subgrades.

Still, the majority of collectors view PSA as the gold standard for sports cards and an equally reputable choice for Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and other TCGs. PSA’s robust population reports, brand recognition, and strong resale values often place it at the top of many collectors’ lists.

Common pitfalls and controversies

Subjective eye appeal
While PSA has clear standards, human graders ultimately assign the grade. Minor differences in interpretation can lead to slight inconsistencies between submissions.
Backlog and delays
During periods of high demand, PSA can experience significant backlog, resulting in lengthy turnaround times. Newcomers should be aware that it could take longer than advertised to get their cards back.
Re-Grade or cracked cases
Some collectors crack open PSA slabs if they believe their card might earn a higher grade if resubmitted. This is a gamble—there’s also a risk the card could receive an even lower grade.
Altered cards
Trimming, recoloring, or pressing out creases to “improve” a card is a major no-no. PSA’s experts are trained to detect such alterations, and if discovered, the card will be labeled “Authentic Altered” or returned ungraded.

Why even low-graded cards can be valuable

Historical rarity
Certain vintage sets (like the T206 baseball series or early 1950s Topps) are incredibly scarce. A well-loved, heavily creased card from these sets can still command thousands or even millions of dollars if it features a legendary player, e.g., Honus Wagner, Babe Ruth, or Mickey Mantle.
Iconic artwork or characters
Some cards transcend their grade because of who or what they depict. A PSA 1 Black Lotus from Magic: The Gathering might still sell for astronomical sums given its status as the holy grail of the TCG world.
Set completion
Vintage set builders or “master set” collectors might accept any graded copy of a difficult card simply to complete their set. A low-grade card can still fill a crucial hole in a collector’s chase.

Real-World Examples of PSA’s Value Boost

PSA 10 1999 Pokémon Charizard (1st Edition Holo)
- Raw copies might fetch a few thousand dollars, but a PSA 10 typically sells in the high five to low six figures, depending on market conditions.
PSA 9 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle
- One of the most iconic post-war cards. While lower-grade Mantles can still fetch six figures, a PSA 9 once sold for millions of dollars.
PSA 1 T206 Honus Wagner
- Despite being in “Poor” condition, it shattered auction records, proving that historical significance and rarity can outweigh a low technical grade.

Conclusion

The PSA grading scale has become the beating heart of the trading card and collectibles market. It delivers a straightforward 1-to-10 grading metric that underscores a card’s condition, drastically influencing its monetary value and ease of trading. By meticulously examining centering, corners, edges, and surface, PSA provides an objective verdict on a card’s quality—a process that fosters confidence and transparency in a hobby that hinges on authenticity and condition.

While many collectors chase the elusive “Gem Mint 10,” it’s important to note that every grade can hold substantial value, especially for legendary or scarce cards. And for modern cards that are fresh from the pack, grading can be the catalyst that transforms an exciting find into a blue-chip collectible. On the other hand, vintage cards are often prized for their storied past, where even a battered card with a PSA 1 grade can command a fortune if it features an iconic subject or comes from a notoriously rare set.

Grading with PSA not only elevates your cards’ market value but also preserves them for decades to come, protecting them in a tamper-proof holder and entering them into a globally recognized database of certified collectibles. Whether you’re a passionate hobbyist or an investor seeking tangible assets, harnessing the PSA grading scale is an essential step toward maximizing the appeal, credibility, and overall worth of your cherished collection.